Add Row
Add Element
cropper
update

Biblical Living Unlocked

Logo - Biblical living unlocked
update
Add Element
  • Home
  • Categories
    • Biblical Parenting
    • Parenting Tips
    • Family Fellowship
    • Bible Teaching
    • Apologetics
    • Community Stories
    • Youth Focus
    • International
    • Walton Evangelical Church
    • Salt Church Mar Menor
    • Salt Church Los Montesinos
    • John Piper
Add Element
  • Ken on Facebook
    update
  • update
  • update
  • update
  • update
  • update
  • update
4 Minutes Read

The Real History of Penal Substitutionary Atonement

How Does Jesus Save Us? Understanding Penal Substitutionary Atonement

By Mike Winger, Simplified and Explained


Introduction: What Did Jesus Do on the Cross?

At the very heart of Christianity is a big question: how does Jesus save us? One way Christians have explained this is through something called Penal Substitutionary Atonement (PSA). That’s a mouthful, but it simply means this:

Jesus took our punishment so we could be forgiven and brought back to God.

This idea is not new. It’s been around since the early days of the Church and is taught clearly in the Bible.

What Does Penal Substitutionary Atonement Mean?

Let’s break it down into three simple parts:

• Penal – This comes from the word penalty. Because of sin, humans deserve a penalty. The Bible says, “The soul that sins shall die” (Ezekiel 18:20). Sin leads to separation from God and death.

• Substitutionary – This means Jesus took our place. He didn’t just die – He died for us. Like it says in Isaiah 53:5, “He was pierced for our transgressions, he was crushed for our iniquities.”

• Atonement – Atonement means to make things right between us and God. Through Jesus’s sacrifice, we are forgiven and made right with God (Romans 5:10).

So, put together: Jesus took the punishment we deserve (penal), in our place (substitution), to bring us back to God (atonement).

Why Do Some People Disagree?

Some modern teachers say PSA is a new idea that started only 500 years ago with a man named John Calvin. They argue that the early church didn’t believe this, and that PSA is based on legal thinking, not love.

But Pastor Mike Winger strongly disagrees. He believes that many early church leaders clearly taught that Jesus took the punishment for our sins.

Let’s look at what some of them said.

What Did Early Christians Believe?

Clement of Rome (c. 95 AD)

“Jesus Christ our Lord gave his blood for us… his body for our bodies, and his soul for our souls.”

This clearly shows substitution – Jesus gave Himself in our place.

Ignatius (c. 107 AD)

“He suffered all these things for our sakes that we might be saved.”

Jesus suffered so that we could be saved – that’s penalty and substitution.

Epistle of Barnabas (c. 70–135 AD)

This early Christian writing quotes Isaiah 53, which talks about the suffering servant taking the punishment for others’ sins.

“He was wounded for our transgressions… and with His stripes we are healed.”

The Epistle to Diognetus (2nd century)

“The righteous one for the unrighteous… Oh sweet exchange!”

This describes the beautiful exchange – Jesus took our place so we could be free.

Justin Martyr (c. 100–165 AD)

“The Father… wished his Christ to take upon himself the curses of all.”

Jesus took on the curse (the penalty) so we could be forgiven.


Isn’t There Another View? What About Christus Victor?

Yes, another way people understand the cross is called Christus Victor, which means “Christ the Victor.” This view says that Jesus defeated sin, death, and the devil.

But here’s the thing: Christus Victor and Penal Substitution are not enemies. They go hand in hand.

• PSA explains how Jesus won the victory (by taking our place).

• Christus Victor explains what the result was (Jesus defeated sin and death).

As Pastor Mike says, “They are sisters, not rivals.”


Does the Bible Support PSA?

Absolutely. The Bible is full of verses that teach penal substitution. Here are a few:

• Isaiah 53:5–6 – “The punishment that brought us peace was on him… the Lord has laid on him the iniquity of us all.”

• 2 Corinthians 5:21 – “God made him who had no sin to be sin for us.”

• Galatians 3:13 – “Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law by becoming a curse for us.”

• 1 Peter 2:24 – “He himself bore our sins in his body on the cross.”

These verses clearly show Jesus took our punishment to make us right with God.


Was God Angry at Jesus?

Some people say PSA makes it sound like God was cruel – even calling it “cosmic child abuse.” But this is a misunderstanding.

Here’s the truth: God was not punishing someone else. God Himself – in the person of Jesus – came to take our place. Jesus said, “No one takes my life from me, but I lay it down of my own accord” (John 10:18).

So, Jesus wasn’t a victim. He willingly gave Himself to save us. “But God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us” (Romans 5:8).


Conclusion: Why It Matters

Penal Substitutionary Atonement shows us two important things:

1. God is holy and just – He does not ignore sin.

2. God is loving and merciful – He took the punishment Himself so we could be saved.

This isn’t a cold, legal idea. It’s the glorious good news of the gospel. It’s about how Jesus saves us by giving His life for ours.


Final Thought

If you ever doubt how much God loves you, just look at the cross. As it says in Isaiah 53:10, “Yet it was the Lord’s will to crush him and cause him to suffer… and the will of the Lord will prosper in his hand.”

God was pleased – not because of the pain – but because Jesus’s death would bring salvation, healing, and new life to anyone who believes.


That’s the heart of Christianity. And that’s why the cross changes everything.


Apologetics

14 Views

0 Comments

Write A Comment

*
*
Related Posts All Posts
11.08.2025

Is Cultural Christianity Diluting Our Faith? A Look into Discipleship

Update Understanding the Cost of Discipleship In a world where the term "Christian" can encompass a myriad of beliefs and practices, peeling back the layers to discover what it truly means to follow Christ is paramount. The video, The Anti-Christian 'Christian', challenges viewers to reflect on their faith commitments and question the authenticity of their discipleship. The contemporary church wrestles with definitions and actions that often deviate from biblical teachings. Discipleship requires more than mere identification with the religion; it demands a transformational relationship with Jesus.The video The Anti-Christian 'Christian' dives into the complexities of modern faith, exploring key insights that prompted deeper analysis on our end. The Dangers of Cultural Christianity Many individuals identify as Christian solely based on cultural practices rather than personal belief or conviction. This scenario, discussed in the video, points to a trend where being 'Christian' is often more about societal acceptance than a genuine commitment to Christ's teachings. Such cultural Christianity can lead believers to adopt anti-Christian behaviors, even while labeling themselves as followers of Christ. This distinction is crucial in understanding how we engage with the world around us. Dissecting Modern Influences Another significant insight from the video relates to how modern influences, such as media and popular culture, shape religious identities. The pervasiveness of secular ideologies can dilute biblical truth, prompting individuals to compromise their beliefs. This dynamic raises questions about the integrity of one’s faith and challenges the church to confront these influences head-on. Authentic Christian living demands an active engagement with Scripture and a willingness to resist societal pressures. The Call to Authenticity The antidote to the superficial faith outlined in the video is a call for authenticity. This call resonates deeply within the context of today's church, where the line between true faith and cultural affiliation can often blur. To genuinely represent Christ, believers must embrace a faith that penetrates their actions, thoughts, and community interactions. In this endeavor, having a firm grasp of biblical principles and historical context can guide the faithful toward understanding their role in the kingdom of God. Practical Insights for Today’s Believers For those striving to navigate these complexities, practical insights become invaluable. Engaging with the Bible regularly, attending healthy church communities, and fostering open conversations about faith can strengthen believers against the pitfalls identified in the video. It's vital to cultivate environments where questioning and discussion are welcomed, allowing individuals to wrestle with their beliefs and grow. Such environments encourage authenticity and help dismantle any anti-Christian actions that could tarnish the church's witness. Confronting Misconceptions One common misconception about Christianity is that it requires perfect adherence to theological principles. However, the reality is that Christianity is about progress in one's relationship with Christ rather than perfection. This view aligns with the Apostle Paul's teachings on grace and restoration, which remind us that recognizing our shortcomings catalyzes spiritual growth. Understanding this principle can alleviate feelings of condemnation and foster a community-centric approach to faith. Community’s Role in Discipleship As highlighted in the video, one of the church’s greatest strengths is its community. Discipleship is not merely an individual pursuit; it thrives in shared experiences among believers who encourage and sharpen one another. This communal approach should involve accountability and mutual support, where individuals assist each other in walking faithfully with Christ. Connecting with churches like Salt Church Los Montesinos and Walton Evangelical Church can provide companionship in this discipleship journey and help tackle societal pressures that threaten authentic faith. Conclusion: Embracing True Discipleship The discussion sparked by The Anti-Christian 'Christian' serves as a valuable reminder of the essence of discipleship. As Christians, we are called to be light in a culture that frequently misrepresents or dilutes our faith. Embracing the full teachings of scripture leads to a deeper understanding and genuine representation of the Christian faith. By cultivating practices that promote authenticity, believers can navigate modern challenges while living out their call in Christ.

11.08.2025

Unraveling the Mystery of Finding God's Will: Insights from Greg Koukl

Update Deciphering God's Will: A Clarity in Biblical Understanding Understanding God’s will is often a profoundly personal and complex journey for many believers. As discussed in the video “The Secret to Finding God's Will” with Greg Koukl, finding clarity in this pursuit can lead to transformative insights, lifting a heavy burden off the shoulders of those who struggle to discern their paths. Many question whether God actively speaks today or if we are merely left to navigate life on our own. Through a scriptural lens, Koukl reveals that this pursuit to discover God’s will is deeply entrenched in tradition rather than scriptural foundation.In ‘The Secret to Finding God's Will,’ the discussion dives into key insights that sparked deeper analysis on our end. Why Tradition vs. Scripture Matters Koukl points to the irony that often a subjective experience is prioritized over scripture—particularly within Protestant communities. This reliance on personal feelings can lead to confusion, as many people feel God is not communicating with them as He might with others, prompting insecurity and doubt. Koukl’s insight that “we may be more committed to a certain subjective experience of how we think God speaks than scripture itself” challenges believers to reconsider their approach. Instead of seeking subjective experiences, they are encouraged to return to biblical scriptures to find guidance and clarity. The Importance of Contextual Understanding One of the key elements in Koukl’s discussion is the concept of context. He emphasizes the principle of never reading a Bible verse in isolation. By understanding the surrounding context of biblical texts referring to God’s will, believers are better equipped to discern what it truly means. Instead of clinging to traditional interpretations, Koukl advocates for a return to the source—a thorough reading of the Bible to understand what it genuinely indicates about God’s desires for His people. God’s Revealed Will vs. Human Expectations God's sovereign will exists as part of a plan beyond our comprehension. Koukl describes this as a hidden aspect of God's character—we may not fully understand His decisions but can trust His sovereignty over our lives. Believers often grapple with seeking specific directives about major life choices, such as marriage or career decisions. The frustration arises when they don't receive clear signals, leading to a search for God’s personal will. Ultimately, Koukl asserts that God's will is not limited to specific directives about our choices but is better understood as a moral framework guiding how we live our lives. Discovering Wisdom Through Scripture In lieu of waiting for nudges and signs, Koukl suggests a proactive approach. He emphasizes that wisdom, derived from prudent engagement with scripture, allows believers to make godly decisions. Through the lenses of moral will and wise counsel, individuals can navigate significant decisions with confidence. By seeking wisdom from the book of Proverbs and engaging in honest conversations with trusted advisors, believers can perceive alternatives and make more informed choices. Practical Steps for Decision-Making What does it look like to make wise decisions according to biblical teachings? Koukl delineates a method involving personal reflection on desires, understanding God’s moral will, and considering wise counsel from others. This tri-fold approach creates a balanced framework that leads to informed decision-making. It fosters a nurturing environment that acknowledges individual desires while remaining rooted in scriptural teaching. The Role of the Holy Spirit Some may ask if the Holy Spirit plays a role in daily decisions. According to Koukl, while the Spirit guides and empowers believers, the expectation that He will provide clear, supernatural nudges for every decision is misguided. Instead, the Spirit works within the framework of wisdom already established in Scripture. Recognizing the distinction between subjective impulses and the Holy Spirit’s guiding influence further encourages believers to rely on a firm biblical foundation. God is not in the habit of mumbling or leaving believers to decipher vague hints. Concluding Thoughts: Move Beyond the Nudge This exploration of God’s will illuminates clear paths for those seeking guidance. The approach Koukl advocates affirms that instead of fixating on subjective feelings, believers are called to return to Scripture to engage thoughtfully with the concepts of God’s will and their own decision-making processes. As they yield themselves to prayer, wise counsel, and biblical truths, they can trust in God’s sovereignty and guidance even when the path ahead may feel uncertain. For those engaged in theological exploration or personal dilemmas, the pursuit of clarity in God’s will does not have to beckon confusion. Instead, as ideas unfold, creating a dialogue around God’s will encourages community and affirmation in the divine purpose—strengthening faith and understanding among seekers. If you find yourself wrestling with decisions, deepen your study and prayer in the word, harness wisdom from those around you, and trust that God is at work in ways beyond your immediate comprehension.

11.08.2025

Understanding Beneficial vs. Permissible: A Christian’s Guide to Freedom in Faith

Update Defining Freedom: Beyond the Surface The concepts of "beneficial" and "permissible" are critical in our understanding of Christian freedom. Many Christians often grapple with what it truly means to live freely in Christ, given that freedom is frequently equated with the ability to do as one pleases. As discussed in the podcast episode 'Beneficial vs. Permissible: It’s More Than Right or Wrong', Paul’s message in 1 Corinthians 10:22-24 emphasizes that while believers may feel free to act, understanding what benefits the Christian community and glorifies God is essential.In 'Beneficial vs. Permissible: It’s More Than Right or Wrong', the discussion delves into the critical distinction between what can be legally done versus what truly benefits our Christian community. Understanding Paul's Message The podcast delves into the historical context behind 1 Corinthians 10, where Paul addresses the early church’s dilemma regarding eating food sacrificed to idols. For new believers, this may feel remote, yet it serves as a relevant point of reflection on how our actions influence others. Just because something is permissible does not mean it is beneficial. Paul reminds us that our freedom should not introduce stumbling blocks for others; rather, our choices should reflect love and concern for the well-being of our community. The Nature of True Freedom Today's culture often celebrates individualism and personal choice without considering the consequences. The podcast asserts that this notion of freedom can be misleading. True freedom is characterized by self-sacrifice and developing virtues that align with God’s will. Unlike the libertarian perspective of freedom as doing whatever one desires, Christianity presents freedom as liberating oneself from sin and worldly desires to serve others. Cultivating Wisdom: A Higher Call Distinguishing between what is permissible and what is wise forms another layer in understanding Christian liberty. As highlighted by the podcast hosts, Christians should prioritize the wisdom behind their actions rather than merely adhering to a checklist of rules. This entails asking deeper questions: "Is this wise? Is this helpful to my spiritual growth and those around me?" This approach not only fosters a mature faith but also encourages believers to live thoughtfully within their communities, echoing the essence of Jesus’s teachings. Counterarguments and Concerns While some may view the guidelines proposed in Scripture as legalistic, it’s important to grasp the distinction between legalism and living out one's faith practically. Legalism often emerges from a desire to earn favor with God through rule-following, while the call to live beneficially stems from a place of existing grace and desire for community-oriented love. Thus, upcoming discussions regarding cultural practices like Halloween present a unique opportunity for believers to decide what aligns with their convictions—focusing on the transformative potential of love rather than rigid rules. Practical Application: Reflecting on Actions As seen in the podcast, making reflective decisions based on love and consideration for others can facilitate a healthy church environment. For parents and youth leaders especially, these conversations are vital regarding activities where the line between beneficial and permissible often blurs. Encouraging youth to ask, "How do my actions reflect love for those around me?" can pave the way for thoughtful dialogue and growth. Conclusion: Moving Forward As we navigate through these complex discussions, it's essential to remember that our journey in faith is not merely about understanding right and wrong but about cultivating a lifestyle that actively seeks the good of others. Engage actively in your faith, not with a checklist, but with an open heart willing to grow in Christ’s image. For those wrestling with similar questions, consider pursuing discipleship opportunities or community discussions that challenge you to expand your understanding of your faith practice. Now, if you want to explore these themes further, consider checking out additional resources around topics of ethical living in faith. Delve into programs that encourage discussions about beneficial practices or connect with community groups fostering mentorship and discipleship in navigating these modern dilemmas.

Terms of Service

Privacy Policy

Core Modal Title

Sorry, no results found

You Might Find These Articles Interesting

T
Please Check Your Email
We Will Be Following Up Shortly
*
*
*